How to get an FMLA lawsuit in one easy step

by Michael Haberman on September 4, 2013 · 0 comments


 

Pay attention to the details.

Pay attention to the details.

The Family and Medical Leave Act turned 20 years old earlier this year, yet it remains problematic for many employers. As an old saying goes “the devil is in the details.” Missing those details is how you get an FMLA lawsuit.

The definition of “equivalent”

According to Fact Sheet #28 on the FMLA Upon return from FMLA leave, an employee must be restored to his or her original job or to an equivalent job with equivalent pay, benefits, and other terms and conditions of employment.” All of this hinges on the definition of “equivalent.” According to the dictionary equivalent means “Equal, as in value, force, or meaning. Having similar or identical effects.”

There are companies in the past that have tried to return people to positions and pay them at the same rate, maintaining their title and benefits. However, the nature of the job had changed. I remember a case where a woman was returned to a VP position in title and pay but one without VP responsibilities. She was doing clerical work, with which  she was unhappy. She sued and won.

More modern case

Jeff Nowak, in his blog post When an Employee Returns from FMLA Leave, What Does Same or Equivalent Position Actually Mean? tells us of a more recent case that is very similar to the one I described. The case was one of a project manager who upon returning to work was put in a position with the same pay, benefits, hours and working conditions. However, the title was different, the nature of the decision making was different, the advancement opportunities were different, and the reporting relationship was different. Nowak reports that the court rejected the employer’s argument that the position was equivalent because it paid the same and offered the same benefits. He quotes the court, which said, “Even if both positions carried equal pay and benefits, if the Quality Analyst II position did not require a similar level of training and education, then it was not equivalent in terms of status and thus the positions would not be equivalent under the FMLA.”

Lessons

The lesson for employers is that when returning someone from FMLA it may be best to put them back into the position they vacated to take leave. However, sometimes you don’t want to do that. You find that the person’s replacement does a job that is so much better than the other person. When that happens then you had better hope that you have a position that offers the same pay, benefits, status, duties, responsibilities, and opportunities. Because if you don’t you will most likely get sued. So plan ahead of time and have a plan that involves temporary replacements and stick to it.


Sign up for free HR Solutions updates via email

Omega HR Solutions, Inc. uses creative human resource solutions to provide answers to time, money and service issues with employers and their employees. Visit our Products and Services page for more information or contact us to learn how we can help your organization.

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: